---

name: code-review-evaluation description: Evaluate code review quality and provide feedback on review effectiveness and thoroughness

Code Review Evaluation Skill

Assess code review quality and improve review processes.

When to Use

• Review process improvement
• Team training
• Quality assurance
• Metrics collection

Evaluation Criteria

1. Coverage: All changes reviewed?
2. Depth: Surface-level or thorough?
3. Timeliness: How long to review?
4. Constructiveness: Helpful feedback?
5. Consistency: Standards applied?

Review Checklist

• Code meets requirements
• No bugs or logic errors
• Follows coding standards
• Tests included and passing
• Documentation updated
• No security vulnerabilities
• Performance considerations
• Error handling adequate

Metrics

• Review turnaround time
• Comments per review
• Approval rate
• Defects found
• Review participation

Best Practices

• Review small changes frequently
• Provide specific, actionable feedback
• Balance criticism with praise
• Focus on code, not person
• Use checklists
• Automate what you can

Resources

• Google Code Review Guidelines: https://google.github.io/eng-practices/review/
• Conventional Comments: https://conventionalcomments.org/