Back to list
WILLOSCAR

survey-seed-harvest

by WILLOSCAR

Research pipelines as semantic execution units: each skill declares inputs/outputs, acceptance criteria, and guardrails. Evidence-first methodology prevents hollow writing through structured intermediate artifacts.

83🍴 10📅 Jan 24, 2026

SKILL.md


name: survey-seed-harvest description: | Identify survey/review papers in a retrieved set and extract taxonomy seeds into outline/taxonomy.yml (topics/subtopics/terminology). Trigger: survey seed harvest, taxonomy seeds, 从 survey 提 taxonomy, bootstrap taxonomy. Use when: retrieval/dedup 后想快速从已有 survey/review 论文中提取术语与主题结构,用于加速 taxonomy-builderSkip if: 已经有高质量 taxonomy(或你不想被 survey 既有框架限制)。 Network: none. Guardrail: 产物是 seed,必须经 taxonomy-builder 重写与对齐 scope;避免生成泛化占位节点。

Survey Seed Harvest

Bootstrap taxonomy seeds from existing survey/review papers inside your retrieved set.

This is an accelerator for the early structure stage: it should make taxonomy-builder easier, not replace it.

Inputs

  • papers/papers_dedup.jsonl (deduped paper metadata with titles/abstracts)

Outputs

  • outline/taxonomy.yml (seed taxonomy; expected to be refined)

Workflow (heuristic)

Uses: papers/papers_dedup.jsonl.

  1. Find likely survey/review papers:
    • title/abstract contains “survey”, “review”, “systematic”, “meta-analysis”
  2. Extract candidate topic terms and group them into:
    • ~4–10 top-level nodes (“chapters”)
    • 2–6 children per node (mappable leaves)
  3. Write short, actionable descriptions:
    • what belongs here / what does not
    • (optional) list 2–5 representative titles as seeds
  4. Treat the result as a starting point:
    • pass it to taxonomy-builder for domain-meaningful rewriting and scope alignment.

Quality checklist

  • outline/taxonomy.yml exists and is valid YAML.
  • Taxonomy has at least 2 levels (children used) and every node has a description.
  • Avoid generic placeholder nodes like “Overview/Benchmarks/Open Problems” unless they are truly content-based for your domain.

Script (optional helper)

Quick Start

  • python .codex/skills/survey-seed-harvest/scripts/run.py --help
  • python .codex/skills/survey-seed-harvest/scripts/run.py --workspace <workspace_dir>

All Options

  • --top-k <n>: number of candidate terms to consider
  • --min-freq <n>: minimum frequency threshold

Examples

  • More conservative term selection:
    • python .codex/skills/survey-seed-harvest/scripts/run.py --workspace <ws> --top-k 80 --min-freq 3

Notes

  • This helper is keyword-based; treat the output as seeds and refine with taxonomy-builder.

Troubleshooting

Issue: no survey/review papers are detected in the set

Fix:

  • Broaden retrieval (add “survey”, “review”, “benchmark” variants) or manually seed a few known surveys, then rerun.

Issue: taxonomy seeds look like generic buckets

Fix:

  • Keep seeds concrete (named methods/benchmarks/tasks) and rely on taxonomy-builder to rewrite under the actual scope.

Score

Total Score

70/100

Based on repository quality metrics

SKILL.md

SKILL.mdファイルが含まれている

+20
LICENSE

ライセンスが設定されている

0/10
説明文

100文字以上の説明がある

+10
人気

GitHub Stars 100以上

0/15
最近の活動

1ヶ月以内に更新

+10
フォーク

10回以上フォークされている

+5
Issue管理

オープンIssueが50未満

+5
言語

プログラミング言語が設定されている

+5
タグ

1つ以上のタグが設定されている

+5

Reviews

💬

Reviews coming soon